Rachel Zoe – To Keep or Not to Keep?

June 3, 2013

Rachel Zoe Scarlett Sandals

I’ve had my eyes on these sandals for awhile, so I was super happy when they went on sale!

I’m a little disappointed. I don’t know if I should keep them? I love the colors, and the material is nice, but two problems:

ONE. They’re TINY – so I don’t know if I should order a size or half a size up?
TWO. The main problem – Every time I walk, my feet slip out in the back, and I don’t think it will be fixed with a bigger size.

I think they’d look great one someone with narrow feet, not wide feet like mine haha.

So, friends, exchange or just return?

  • Ice Pandora

    What a bummer about these
    adorable looking shoes :c
    well, I can tell you one
    thing: uncomfy shoes are
    real torture for your
    feet. Xx

  • weheartbeautyblog

    I think they are beautiful and I loooove the colors! But if you don’t think you’re going to wear them then I would definitely exchange them for something you will use. Just my two cents!

    xox Lara http://www.weheartbeautyblog.com

  • & Pretty Things

    They’re so cute! But if they don’t fit comfortably, I’d say to return them. Uncomfortable or ill-fitting shoes are the worst. :)

    & Pretty Things

  • ℐ.

    I think they’re really cute! But like others have said, if they aren’t comfortable, I’d return them or exchange them at least. I do love the color though!


  • SimplyxClassic

    those are sooo cute!!! BUT if they don’t fit right and you don’t think a bigger size will help, don’t bother. it’ll be a waste of money.

  • Courtney Ramsey

    hmm I hate that feeling when you get something you’ve been wanting but they end up not being as wonderful as you had wanted them to be.

    I agree that a bigger size won’t solve the foot slipping part. So even tho they are so super cute, I vote return. Shoes that cause walking problems are a no go! :)

    xo, Courtney

  • libys11

    i love the style and color!! i think it will suit your wardrobe but at the same time, if it doesn’t fit right, i don’t think you should keep it. at least i’m like this with the pieces in my closet. even though at times i see something really wonderful in store, when i try them on and they don’t fit in the right places, i tend to pass up on them. luckily, i do end up finding something else that fits better.. I’m sure you’re going to find something else that’s as nice or better than that pair. :D

    Click me for my BLOG!

  • Elle

    Aww that’s too bad! They’re definitely cute but I would return them if the fit is off – you’ll definitely find other pretty shoes worth spending the $ on!

  • Stephanie Lula

    Uh oh :O This is a huge keep. I would get a different size if you really love them. keep the one you have now and get the different size and see if it makes a difference. It’s unfortunate about the feet slipping, because they are so cute.

  • ashlyn williams

    i hate when i get a pair of shoes and that happens. my moto, if i am not in love i return!

    but they are super cute!


  • Joy

    These are so cute. Bring it to the cobblers perhaps? Wish you the best of luck.

  • Marley

    Those are so cute but you do wanna be comfortable in a pair of shoes and not have to worry about slipping!

    I dont know :(

  • fizz

    They are definitely cute! I love the color! But if the size is not right, I say return them =(

  • drinkcitra

    Ahh! What a hard decision…I feel like I go through this a lot with shoes. They’re really cute, but if you’re iffy about them, maybe let them go? If you were going somewhere, would these be your first choice to wear? These questions always come up when I’m iffy about keeping something that I thought I was going to fully love…
    Eek! Good luck! I’ll back you up with whichever decision you make :D

  • Jamie @ jforjamie.com

    Ugh, I’ve been on a summer sandal hunt and I just can’t seem to find the right shoe. I say, if they’re not perfect/comfortable/exactly what you’re looking for, return them and keep lookin’. It’s not like we don’t have plenty of options!

  • jessica {creative index}

    They are SO adorable, but if the fit isn’t right, return them! Un-comfy shoes are the worst!

  • Ladies in Navy

    these are gorgeous! exchange or return. you’ll never be happy with them and in the summer, you need an easy, cute, sandal that doesn’t give you any issues!
    kw ladies in navy

  • Sandy a la Mode

    awwww they are gorgeous shoes!! but they should fit how you want them too… :/

    Sandy a la Mode

  • Rhonda Mae

    Aw man, I hate when that happens!! They really are beautiful. I just read your more recent post and saw that you’ll be returning them! I know you’re going to find a pair of sandals like these (or even better) that will just be perfect :) I’m putting it out into the universe!! <33

  • Rosie

    i’d say straight up return, because if it were me I know that I just wouldn’t wear them if they didn’t fit right! Then you can spend your pennies on another equally pretty but far more comfy pair! :)


  • Gena Palmieri

    Lovely shoes and blog darling! Absolutely adorable.
    Blush and Blossoms

  • La Dolce Moda

    I love these!
    The pink is so pretty :)